The Swedish blog imperhia has published the article Skapandet av knullgubbar where the author speculates how male abusers are raised. The author’s main argument is that adult violence stems from the acceptance of boys’ violence as children. The solution is to not accept boys’ violent behaviour.
The author’s line of reasoning starts with a personal anecdote, where her daughter has been kicked by a boy in school. This was not a single event, but rather one in a series of events of physical harassment. So the author asks her child whether her teacher had done anything about these occurrences, and her child answers that her teacher has opposed the assaults verbally, but the boy has not ceased the abuse.
The author then confronts her daughter’s teacher regarding the situation and the teacher’s answer is that the author’s daughter is popular among the boys, and that she needs to say no more clearly.
It is att this point the author gets angry. Her daughter should not learn to say no clearly, and makes parallels to rape cases where the victim hasn’t said no clearly enough. Her daughter should not have to learn to say no, it is the boy who should cease his dysfunctional behaviour.
The solution is that we should talk to the violent boys. We should not accept their behaviour. We should hug them instead and make them understand that it is ok for boys to cry as well. We should love the aggression away.
Let’s just wait a minute here. I think everyone can agree not to tolerate violence between kids nor adults. Yet, it exists as the author has made clear to us.
I am sure that the teacher has done everything the author asks for: disapproved of violent behaviour, talked to the violator and most probably hugged him at some time or other. Clearly it hasn’t helped.
We can understand the author’s motives and concur with them as well. But when it comes to the acute moment of abuse, neither love nor any meek behaviour will diminish the abuser’s violence. Actually, that kind of behaviour is the ultimate self sacrificing act.
I believe, regardless of the article’s author’s consternation, that the teacher was right. In any situation of violent abuse, there are mainly three strategies that work.
Immediately, as a victim of an assault you must show non-acceptance, by telling or shouting your opposition, or by hitting back.
Secondly, you should make others aware of the abuse. In an acute situation, you may shout for help to bypassers. When it comes to abuse within a relationship, tell everyone you know: your friends, your family, the police, the abuser’s family and friends. Tell strangers, tell anyone who might be able to help you.
Thirdly, get away from the abuser as soon as possible. Ask for help from your peers, friends and family. Though, it might seem not in the situation, everyone is eager to help a victim of abuse.
Now, the attentive might see that the abused daughter of the story has gone through all of these phases, perhaps without saying no strongly enough. Though, she has told her teacher and her parents. It is possible to relegate the boy in question and force him to change classes or school.
If all of these steps has been taken without sufficient effect, there is a fourth step. But before I present the fourth step, I’d like to retrace the situation a bit.
Most of us raise our children to respect others, physically as well as psychologically. But not all children are raised in that way. Some children are themselves victims of abuse, and we know that these children become abusers themselves.
Surely, we can try to teach abused children respect. We can try to hug them and love them and so on. But in some cases, this will not help. Some children will grow up into adult individuals who turn out to be aggressive and beat other people.
Abusers and psychopaths of different kinds see others as prays or predators. They will only listen to the rule of power, and power only. You can only force these people, by showing them that you have more power than them.
The fourth action for a victim of abuse is to show his assailant a power demonstration. The victim needs to bite back and do it hard. Or as Johnny Depp’s mother told him during his childhood. I wish that someone had told me that before I went to school. And I will surely tell my children the very same thing.
If your are a victim of domestic violence and need more help, there is a great TED talk by Leslie Morgan Steiner I strongly recommend.